We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our data privacy statement.



From euro 14.5 million to euro 900,000: The “Deutsche Wohnen” court ruling and its significance

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​published on 23 June 2026 | reading time approx. 3 minutes

​

In its decision of June 9, 2026 (Case No. 526 OWi LG 1/20), the Berlin Regional Court I issued an important ruling on the enforcement of administrative fines under the GDPR. 

The court reduced the original fine of approximately 14.5 million euros, imposed by the Berlin Commission-er for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BInBDI) in 2019, to 900,000 euros. This decision is of fundamental importance for German and European data protection law, as it clarifies key issues regarding liability under data protection law while also establishing reliable standards for judicial review of administrative fines.

Facts of the Case​​

The proceeding was based on the specific accusation that the real estate company Deutsche Wohnen SE had, over an extended period of time, operated an electronic archiving system for storing tenant data that did not include a functional data deletion policy. As a result, personal data—including pay slips, tax information, and employment contracts—was permanently archived without ongoing verification of whether the storage was still necessary or legally permit-ted. The data protection supervisory authority classified this as a violation of the principles of data minimization and storage limitation under Article 5(1)(c) and (e) of the GDPR, as well as a violation of the obligation to use privacy-friendly default settings under Article 25(1) of the GDPR.

Decision of the European Court of Justice​​

The Berlin Regional Court had initially dismissed the case in 2021 on the grounds that, under German administrative offense law, the imposition of a fine requires that liability be attributable to a natural person. However, in December 2023, following a referral from the Court of Ap-peal in Berlin, the European Court of Justice ruled that such attribution is not required. At the same time, it emphasized that liability is not strict liability and that the company must therefore be found at least negligent.

Criteria for a Reduction in the Fine​​

Taking these EU legal requirements into account, the Regional Court ruled that Deutsche Wohnen had intentionally violated Article 5(1)(c) and (e) of the GDPR. In addition, violations of Article 6 of the GDPR were identified. However, the court adjusted the fine within the scope of its own discretion. The significant reduction in the fine resulted from an assessment of the circumstances of the case. The delay in implementing the required data erasure plan was not due to an attempt to cut costs but was primarily the result of technical and organizational problems associated with migrating from older systems. Furthermore, the court viewed the company’s conduct following the discovery of the violations as a significant factor in its favor. Immediately after receiving the first official warnings, Deutsche Wohnen SE had invested financial and human resources to redesign its entire IT infrastructure in compliance with data protection regulations and to cooperate transparently with the authorities. In the court’s view, the sanction must always be proportionate to the specific degree of fault and the severity of the allegation.

Significance of the Decision​​

The decision of the Regional Court clarifies the requirements for an effective defense in data protection fine proceedings. Since proof of individual fault is no longer required for the imposition of a sanction, the focus of the defense now shifts to exonerating the defendant regarding the degree of fault and to demonstrating that compliance structures are functioning effectively. At the same time, the decision underscores the importance of judicial proceedings to review the amount of the fine. In practice, this means that comprehensive documentation of compliance measures and prompt cooperation in the event of regulatory objections are key factors in significantly reducing risk.​

Tech & Data Bites

author

Contact Person Picture

Sabine Schmitt

Attorney at Law (Germany)

Manager

+49 911 9193 3710

Send inquiry

Rödl Germany

Discover more about our offices in Ger​many​​. Re​​a​d more »​​
Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Deutschland Weltweit Search Menu