We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our data privacy statement.



Intragroup Services and Transfer Pricing: The “Benefit Test” as a Key Condition for Deductibility

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​published on 29 April 2026 | reading time approx. 4 minutes​​


With judgment no. 5753 dated 13 March 2026, the Italian Supreme Court once again addressed one of the most sensitive topics in transfer pricing: intragroup services. This area has historically been characterized by a high level of tax audit risk, with the tax authorities increasingly focusing not only on the level of remuneration, but also on the actual usefulness and economic relevance of the services received by the beneficiary company.

The recent ruling forms part of a now well‑established body of case law and provides practical guidance on the requirements that must be met, from an operational perspective, in order for intragroup service costs to be considered tax deductible.

The Facts of the Case and the Supreme Court’s Position

The dispute arose from a tax audit carried out on KAI S.r.l., an Italian company within the Shell group, which had received cost recharges from its UK affiliate under two Cost Contribution Agreements relating to management support services and research and development activities.

According to the Italian Revenue Agency, a significant portion of the recharged costs did not generate a direct and specific benefit for the Italian company, but instead qualified as:
  • general group coordination activities;
  • typical shareholder functions (so‑called “shareholder activities”); 
  • services lacking a concrete link to the operational needs of the Italian subsidiary.

Although the lower tax courts had ruled in favor of the taxpayer - based on general considerations regarding the usefulness of the services and the “lean” structure of the Italian company - the Supreme Court criticized this approach.

According to the Court, the deductibility of intragroup service costs cannot be based on assumptions or generic considerations, but requires a detailed and analytical verification of the link between:
  • the individual services rendered;
  • the specific operational requirements of the beneficiary company.

Referring to well‑settled case law, the Supreme Court reiterates that the burden of proof lies with the taxpayer and that the benefit must be effective (or at least potential), objectively identifiable and adequately documented.

Of particular interest is the clarification that an incorrect reference in the tax assessment notice to Article 110(7) of the Italian Income Tax Code (“TUIR”), instead of Article 109(5) TUIR, does not result in the invalidity of the assessment, provided that the factual grounds for the tax adjustment are clearly and analytically set out.

While this statement is consistent with a judicial approach that emphasizes the economic substance of the tax claim, it may nonetheless raise certain concerns from a systematic perspective. In principle, the Supreme Court is primarily tasked with reviewing formal defects of tax assessments, and an incorrect reference to the applicable legal provision constitutes, in itself, a formal error.

Observations on Intragroup Se​rvices

In line with the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, as well as with the current Italian transfer pricing regulations, the Supreme Court confirms that the “benefit test” must be satisfied in a concrete and substantive manner.

The ruling highlights a number of important considerations for the management and defense of intragroup services:
  • Burden of proof on the taxpayer: The beneficiary company must demonstrate the existence, relevance and usefulness of the service;1​
  • Concrete, not generic, benefit: It is not sufficient to claim that a service “supports the business” or “creates group synergies”; the benefit must be identifiable and attributable to specific processes, functions or decisions;
  • Clear distinction from shareholder activities: Governance, group‑wide strategy, reporting to the group’s top management or investor‑protection activities are, as a rule, not chargeable to subsidiaries, as they are carried out in the interest of the group or the shareholder and do not meet a specific operational need of a stand‑alone entity;
  • Insufficiency of formal documentation alone: Contracts and invoices are necessary but not sufficient; substantive evidence is required to demonstrate what was done, how, when and for whom;
  • No duplication of services: Intragroup services must not duplicate functions already performed internally or outsourced to independent third parties.

From an operational standpoint, the decision emphasizes the need to go beyond the mere formal preparation of transfer pricing documentation, strengthening consistency between policies, documentation and day‑to‑day operations.

In particular, it is advisable to:
  • map intragroup services, clearly identifying their content, the parties involved, the functions impacted and the business processes supported;
  • substantiate the benefit through concrete evidence such as KPIs, deliverables, reports, presentations, ticketing systems, internal correspondence or activity tracking;
  • ensure consistency between Master File, Local File and internal policies, making sure that they accurately reflect the actual provision of services and avoid excessively vague or generic descriptions.

Con​​clusion

Judgment no. 5753/2026 confirms a strict but now well‑defined approach: in the context of intragroup services, the benefit cannot be presumed. It must be demonstrated, analyzed and supported by operational evidence. For multinational groups, this entails enhanced governance over intragroup services and closer integration between transfer pricing, business processes and management control.​​



[1] Cf. Article 2697 of the Italian Civil Code; Article 109, paragraph 5, of the Italian Income Tax Code (TUIR)

from our newsletter

​​​​​Tax New​sletter​​​​​​

author

Contact Person Picture

Simon Baumgartner

Degree in Economy (Italy)

Associate Partner

+39 0471 1943 200

Send inquiry

Profile

Contact Person Picture

Christian Franchetto

Degree in Economy (Italy)

Senior Associate

+39 0471 1943 200

Send inquiry

Profile

our services

Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Deutschland Weltweit Search Menu