We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our data privacy statement.



Pre-deductible financing to ensure business continuity: what the provision states and why it does not apply to the simplified composition with creditors

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​published on October 6th ​2026 | reading time approx. 7 ​minutes​​​

​

Article 99 of the CCII allows a debtor who has filed (or is about to file) an application for a composition with creditors to ask the court for authorisation to take out loans which, in the event of subsequent insolvency, would be repaid in priority to other claims (so-called ‘pre-deductible’ loans).

Paragraph 1 of the article states:
"With the application for admission [...] or subsequently, the debtor, where the continuation of business operations is envisaged – even if solely for the purposes of liquidation – may apply to the court for authorisation, even prior to the filing of the documentation to be attached to the application, to take out loans in any form, including requests for the issuance of guarantees, which are pre-deductible, necessary for the conduct of the business until the approval of the composition with creditors or debt restructuring agreements, or until the commencement and conduct of such proceedings, and in any event necessary to ensure the best possible satisfaction of creditors."

In essence, the provision requires three conditions: that the financing serves to continue the company’s business (even if only to facilitate a better liquidation); that the debtor is unable to secure these resources elsewhere; and that without the financing, there would be serious prejudice to the company or to the proceedings. The court shall decide by means of a reasoned order within ten days (paragraph 3) and may also authorise security to cover the loan (paragraph 4).

The simplified composition procedure: a different process 

The simplified composition procedure for the liquidation of assets (Articles 25-sexies and 25-septies of the CCII) is a procedure to which the entrepreneur may only have recourse after negotiations for a negotiated settlement of the crisis have failed, and when the expert certifies that the negotiations were conducted in good faith but failed to identify any restructuring solutions.

Compared to the ordinary composition with creditors, the simplified composition is much more streamlined: there is no formal admission phase, a full certification of the plan is not required, creditors do not vote on the proposal, and competing proposals are not permitted.

Paragraph 2 of the same article lists the effects that arise upon publication of the application namely "the effects referred to in Articles 6, 46, 94 and 96". Article 99 of the CCII does not appear amongst these.

To understand why this omission is significant, one must begin with Article 6 of the CCII, which exhaustively lists the claims eligible for priority deduction. Paragraph 1 states: "in addition to the claims expressly designated as such by law, the following are eligible for priority deduction: a) claims relating to expenses and fees for services rendered [by the body responsible for resolving the over-indebtedness crisis]; (b) professional claims arising in connection with the application for the approval of debt restructuring agreements or a restructuring plan subject to approval […]; (c) professional claims arising in connection with the filing of an application for a composition with creditors […]; d) claims legally arising [...] during judicial or supervised liquidation proceedings or following an application for access to a crisis or insolvency resolution mechanism."

The Court of Cassation, in its judgment no. 2779 of 8 February 2026 (Presiding Judge Terrusi, Reporting Judge Crolla), clarified that this list is exhaustive and admits no exceptions beyond the cases provided, for: ‘the statutory provisions on priority claims are undoubtedly of an exceptional and exhaustive nature, in that they derogate from the principles of general financial liability and par condicio creditorum; consequently, an extension by analogy beyond the cases provided for by the law is not permissible.’ According to the Court, the legislature deliberately removed the old, more open-ended wording of Article 111 of the Bankruptcy Act (which allowed priority set-off even for claims arising simply ‘by virtue’ of the proceedings) in order to limit the costs borne by the assets available to creditors.

In the same judgement, the Court of Cassation reiterated that the simplified composition with creditors is ‘an autonomous institution and not a variant of the composition with creditors under the preventive procedure,"highlighting the structural differences already mentioned: the absence of an admission phase, the lack of the certifications typical of the composition with creditors under the preventive procedure, the absence of a creditors’ vote, and the impossibility of competing proposals. Hence the conclusion, in the case in question relating to the priority deduction of fees payable to professionals assisting the debtor, that ‘priority cannot be granted to the claim held by the professional for assistance in drawing up the plan and submitting the application for a simplified composition under Article 25-sexies of the CCII, as this case does not fall within the typical and exhaustive grounds for priority provided for in Article 6 of the Crisis Code."

Applying the same reasoning to interim financing, the courts of first instance (including the Court of Monza, by order of 9 September 2026) have refused authorisation to enter into pre-deductible loans under Article 99 of the CCII in the simplified composition with creditors, on the basis of the same two grounds: the exceptional nature of the rules on pre-deduction, which prohibits the analogous application of Article 99 of the CCII outside the context of a composition with creditors; and the structural autonomy of the simplified composition with creditors, which prevents the automatic extension to it of instruments designed for a different procedure.

A critical analysis: going concern as the path to a better liquidation

Whilst this approach is consistent with the statutory framework and the restrictive stance of the
Court of Cassation, it is open to a criticism that merits consideration, and which concerns precisely the practical purpose of the institution.

The simplified composition is, by definition, a liquidation -based composition. However, Article 99(1) of the CCII itself expressly recognises that the continuation of business operations may also serve to achieve a better liquidation, in that it provides that financing may support business operations "even if solely for the purposes of liquidation." This means that the legislator itself, in regulating the composition with creditors, has recognised that keeping the business in operation, even temporarily, can increase the recoverable value for creditors compared to a piecemeal liquidation of assets. A functioning business with a customer base, employees, and active commercial relationships, is normally worth more than a collection of assets broken up and sold individually.

If this principle holds true in a liquidation-based composition with creditors, there is no substantial reason to exclude it a priori in a simplified composition, which pursues the same objective of maximising the satisfaction of creditors through liquidation. The most typical case– and one that is not uncommon in practice – is that of a company which has received an offer to purchase the business as a going concern: if operations cease before the sale is finalised, then the company loses value, its customer base disperses, employees leave, and the offer may fall through or be drastically reduced. In such cases, ruling out from the outset the possibility of pre-deductible financing risks undermining the very objective that the pre-deduction rule, taken as a whole, is intended to serve: the best possible satisfaction of creditors.

The argument that the grounds for pre-deduction must be strictly defined, whilst correct from a formal point of view, risks producing a counterintuitive effect: preventing, for reasons of interpretative rigour, precisely the transaction that the pre-deduction system is intended to encourage, namely financing aimed at preserving the company’s value in the interests of creditors. The distinction between a liquidation-type composition with creditors and a simplified composition, whilst real from a procedural standpoint (absence of a vote, of full certification, and of an admission phase), does not affect the economic substance of the transaction: in both cases, the issue is whether the temporary continuation of business operations increases the value to be distributed to creditors.

A more balanced solution might therefore consist not in the automatic and a priori exclusion of pre-deductible debt from the scope of the simplified composition with creditors, but in granting the court the power to assess each case individually, in a manner similar to that already provided for in Article 99 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the composition with creditors: to verify in practice, on the basis of an independent assessment, whether the requested financing is genuinely necessary and instrumental to preserving the continuity of the business with a view to a more favourable liquidation, and whether its absence would result in serious prejudice to the recoverable value for the benefit of creditors. Such judicial scrutiny, tailored to the specific circumstances of each procedure, would make it possible to balance the need for cost containment and the strict application of the pre-deduction rule – which inspired the reform – with the substantive protection of creditors’ interests in maximising the proceeds, which is the ultimate purpose of both the composition with creditors and the simplified composition.

Ultimately, the restrictive approach of case law, whilst rooted in the literal wording and consistent with the historical development of the rules governing pre-deductions, sacrifices a substantive assessment that would otherwise be consistent with the rationale behind the institution: the best possible satisfaction of creditors through the preservation, where possible, of the enterprise’s value.

It would be desirable to see intervention– if not legislative, then at least interpretative – which recognises the court’s power to authorise interim financing even in a simplified composition with creditors, where such financing is specifically and concretely aimed at preserving the continuity of the business in the interests of creditors, rather than being generically extended to every financial need arising from the proceedings.

from our newsletter

Legal Newsletter​​​​​​​

author

Contact Person Picture

Giorgia Maschera

Attorney at Law (Italy)

Associate Partner

+39 049 8046 911

Send inquiry

Profile

Contact Person Picture

Giovanni Fonte

Certified Tax Consultant, Statutory Auditor (Italy)

Partner

+39 049 8046 911

Send inquiry

Profile

Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Deutschland Weltweit Search Menu