We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our data privacy statement.



Pay Transparency: The Introduction of Job Evaluation in the Company

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​published on 28 April 2026 | reading time approx. 3 minutes​

​

One of the most relevant - yet so far often overlooked - aspects concerns the assessment of the value of work together with the workers’ representatives (so-called “RSA/RSU”) present within the company.

The job evaluation criteria in the EU-Directive No. 2023/970

A central - and until now often underestimated - element of the new regulatory framework is the evaluation of the value of work. Article 4 par. 4 of the Directive provides that the criteria adopted to assess the value of job positions must be:
  • objective;
  • gender-neutral;
  • based on factors such as skills, responsibilities, effort, working conditions and, where appropriate, other factors relevant to the specific job or position.

A key element - of particular relevance for industrial relations – is that these criteria must be agreed with workers’ representatives, where such representatives exist. The Directive therefore does not merely impose a unilateral obligation on the employer but requires the active involvement of trade union representatives in defining the evaluation parameters.

The regulation in the draft of the Italian implementing decree

The current version of the draft of the Italian legislative decree implementing the Directive does not appear to fully transpose this provision.

Regarding the assessment of the value of work (job grading), the proposed framework makes rather generic reference to the classifications and job categories provided for by the national collective bargaining agreements (NCBA), presuming their compliance with the principles of equal pay and transparency.

This approach raises several operational concerns:
  • many job classification descriptions provided by NCBAs refer to a wide range of tasks;
  • the same task (or set of tasks characterizing a position) may have a different value depending on the specific features of the individual organization;
  • many job roles involve hybrid tasks.

The categories derived from NCBA classifications are often insufficient to describe the complexity of company roles, and the pay ranges applied to workers classified within the same level may be very wide.

This may result in significant difficulties for the employer in justifying pay differences between workers performing different jobs that formally fall within the same contractual classification.

According to the current draft, employer-defined professional classification systems are also permitted, but only as an addition to the classification framework already set out in the applicable NCBA.

In its evident attempt to simplify a complex matter, the draft legislative decree runs counter to the clear invitation of the Directive to enhance collective bargaining and the role of trade unions.

It is, however, foreseeable and indeed desirable that, during the final approval process, the Italian legislator will address this shortcoming, aligning more faithfully with Article 4 par. 4 of the Directive.

Given that only a few weeks remain before the Directive becomes fully applicable, it is strongly recommended to carry out an internal analysis of job roles that goes beyond the mere NCBA job descriptions. This is essential to avoid being unprepared in June, when workers - also through their representatives - will have the right to request and obtain access to the criteria used by the employer to assess the value of individual job positions.

Operational implications for employers

In view of the full applicability of the Directive as from 7 June 2026, it is essential to:
  • verify whether existing grading systems are actually based on objective and transparent criteria or, where this is not the case, implement appropriate systems;
  • assess the need to initiate, as soon as possible, a structured dialogue with workers’ representatives on job evaluation modalities.

from our newsletter

Legal​ Newsletter​​​​​​​

author

Contact Person Picture

Rita Santaniello

Attorney at Law (Italy)

Partner

+39 02 6328 841

Send inquiry

Profile

Contact Person Picture

Giovanni Zoja

Attorney at Law (Italy)

Partner

+39 02 6328 841

Send inquiry

Profile

Contact Person Picture

Rebecca Salat

Attorney at Law (Italy)

Manager

+39 02 6328 841

Send inquiry

Profile

Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Deutschland Weltweit Search Menu