We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our data privacy statement.



Business valuation in the CNDCEC-SIDREA Guidelines on the sustainability of start-ups

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​published on 17 July ​2026 | reading time approx. 5​​ ​minutes​​​


Start-ups play an increasingly significant role in innovation, economic growth and the creation of new skilled jobs. At the same time, they are among the most complex types of business to analyse and value. Business models still undergoing validation, a lack of consolidated historical data, a high proportion of intangible assets and often substantial financial requirements make the valuation of start-ups a fundamentally different exercise from that of mature companies.

It is against this backdrop that the recent Guidelines on the Sustainability of Start-ups, published by CNDCEC and SIDREA, have been issued. These offer a useful framework not only for start-up founders and investors, but also for professionals, managers, financial institutions and stakeholders interested in understanding the true economic and strategic sustainability of young companies.

The issue of sustainability is addressed in a broad sense. It is not merely a question of ESG sustainability, but of the start-up’s ability to chart a credible growth path that is financially sustainable and consistent with its target market. Business valuation thus becomes a tool not only for assigning an economic value to the company, but also for assessing the soundness of the business venture.

Why valuing a start-up is different​​

In mature companies, valuation can normally be based on historical results, recurring cash flows, established profit margins and observable market benchmarks. In start-ups, these elements are often absent or not particularly representative. A young company may report losses in its early years, still have limited revenue, and be making significant investments in technological development, staff, marketing and customer acquisition.

A purely accounting-based analysis therefore risks being misleading. Initial losses do not necessarily indicate a problematic situation but may represent a natural phase of investment. The key is to understand whether these investments are consistent with a scalable business model and a realistic prospect of value creation.

For this reason, the valuation of start-ups must look beyond the financial statements. It is necessary to analyse the quality of the entrepreneurial team, the defensibility of the technology, the size of the potential market, the intensity of competition, the ability to acquire customers and the potential to achieve economies of scale.

The business plan as the foundation of value​​

The Guidelines assign a central role to the business plan, viewed not merely as a descriptive document, but as a tool for planning, monitoring and preventing the main critical issues facing young businesses.

In the case of start-ups, the business plan is the essential information base for the valuation. It is through the plan that consistency is verified between the business idea, commercial strategy, cost structure, financial requirements and the timeframe for reaching break-even. A credible plan must translate the business vision into measurable economic and financial assumptions, avoiding forecasts that are overly optimistic or not supported by market evidence.

The valuation therefore depends on the quality of the underlying assumptions: expected revenue growth, future profit margins, necessary investments, working capital, available liquidity and the ability to finance growth. From this perspective, indicators such as burn rate and cash runway play a central role, as they measure the start-up’s ability to survive until it achieves financial sustainability.

The limitations of traditional methods​​

Whilst traditional methodologies remain useful, they must be applied with caution. The financial method based on discounting future cash flows is theoretically sound, but it has clear limitations when applied to start-ups: projected cash flows are highly uncertain, future profit margins are often difficult to estimate, and the terminal value can carry excessive weight relative to the overall value.

The multiples method can also prove problematic. Comparison with peer companies presupposes the existence of firms that are similar in terms of sector, business model, stage of development and risk profile. In innovative start-ups, however, such comparability is often limited, particularly when the company operates in new markets or with business models that are not yet fully established.

For this reason, the Guidelines suggest a more adaptive approach, based on scenarios, adjustments for the risk of failure, illiquidity, differences in equity rights and the use of forward multiples, such as forward EV/Sales.

Adaptive valuation methods, intangible assets and sustainability​​

The approaches referred to in the Guidelines also include the Venture Capital Method and the First Chicago Method. The former focuses in particular on the value the start-up is likely to achieve at the time of exit and on the return expected by the investor. The latter, by contrast, combines various scenarios — pessimistic, intermediate and optimistic — to better reflect the uncertainty typical of young companies.

These methods have the advantage of interpreting valuation not as a single point estimate, but as a range of possible outcomes. This approach is particularly well-suited to start-ups, where the risk of failure coexists with very high growth potential.

Another key factor is intangible assets. Technology, know-how, software, patents, data, reputation, strategic relationships and the team’s expertise can constitute the most significant part of the value, even if they are not always fully reflected in the accounts. The valuation must therefore integrate quantitative and qualitative analyses, considering not only what the start-up possesses, but also its ability to transform these resources into a competitive advantage.

In this context, sustainability takes on a concrete meaning. A sustainable start-up is one that can grow without compromising its financial stability, attract capital, manage risks and establish a governance structure appropriate to its development. ESG factors also play a part in the assessment, as they influence reputation, access to finance, relationships with customers and partners, and the quality of decision-making processes.

Conclusions​​

The valuation of a start-up cannot be reduced to the mechanical application of financial formulas. It requires a comprehensive analysis of the business model, the business plan, intangible assets, liquidity, risks and the overall sustainability of the project.

In this regard, the CNDCEC-SIDREA Guidelines provide a useful framework for viewing valuation not merely as the determination of a price, but as an assessment of the start-up’s ability to transform its potential into lasting value. Ultimately, valuing a start-up means asking not only how much it can grow, but also to what extent that growth is genuinely credible, financeable and sustainable over time.​

from our newsletter

​​​​​Tax Newsletter​​​​​​​

author

Contact Person Picture

Paolo Zani

Certified Tax Consultant, Statutory Auditor (Italy)

Associate Partner

+39 02 6328 841

Send inquiry

Profile

Contact Person Picture

Mirco Binazzi

Certified Tax Consultant (Italy)

Senior Associate

+39 02 6328 841

Send inquiry

Profile

our services

​​​​Valuation

Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Deutschland Weltweit Search Menu