We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our data privacy statement.



“Parent–subsidiary” exemption: the late filing of the tax certificate does not invalidate the entitlement to the exemption

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​published on 3 July ​2026 | reading time approx. 4 ​minutes​

​

The Italian Court of Cassation has confirmed that the right to exemption from withholding tax on dividends distributed by Italian companies to EU parent companies cannot be denied solely because of a delay in submitting the required tax certificate, provided that the substantive eligibility requirements are met.

At the heart of the case dealt with in order n.13128/2026 lies a question of immediate practical importance for any multinational group: can a delay in submitting a required document result in the loss of a tax exemption, even when all the substantive conditions for claiming that exemption are fully met? The Court of Cassation's answer is no.  Article 27-bis of Presidential Decree n. 600/1973, which implements the EU Parent-Subsidiary Directive, provides that the certificate attesting compliance with the relevant requirements must be obtained before the dividend distribution is made. However, according to the Italian Supreme Court, failure to comply with this deadline is not, in itself, sufficient to deny the exemption: submitting the document late is merely a technical irregularity, which does not affect the right to exemption.

The case arose from the distribution, in 2007, of dividends by an Italian company to its Danish parent company. At the time of payment, the Italian company had already applied the exemption regime provided for under art. 27-bis, although it had not yet received the certificate issued by the danish tax authority – the document certifying the parent company’s tax residence and the fulfilment of the other conditions required under the legislation. The certification was issued only a few days after the dividend payment.

The Italian Revenue Agency determined that the failure to obtain the certificate by the time of payment precluded the application of the exemption and therefore recovered the withholding tax that had not been withheld, together with interest and penalties.

Both the provincial tax court and the regional tax court ruled in favour of the company, holding that the foreign parent company satisfied all the substantive requirements laid down by the legislation and that the delay in producing the certificate constituted a mere formal irregularity, with no impact on the right to the exemption.

The judges further held that a different interpretation would be contrary to the principles of cooperation and good faith that must govern the relationship between the tax authorities and taxpayers. With regard to the Italian Revenue Agency’s objection – according to which the company should have first applied the withholding tax and then claimed a refund – the regional tax court noted that such an approach would have resulted in entirely unnecessary procedural burdens, without any benefit to the Treasury, and that therefore the Italian company’s conduct could not be criticised.

The ruling is not an isolated one but forms part of a now well-established line of decisions. Already with  judgment n. 27646 of 29 September 2023, the Italian Court of Cassation had made clear that the late submission of the certificate issued by the foreign tax authority does not undermine the parent company’s entitlement to the exemption from withholding tax on Italian dividends, when the requirements laid down by the Parent-Subsidiary Directive are in any event satisfied.

On that occasion, the Court further clarified that the requirement to obtain the certificate before payment is intended to protect the Italian distributing company, enabling it to assess whether to apply the exemption requested by the foreign parent company immediately. If the Italian company chooses not to apply withholding tax even in the absence of complete documentation, the exemption remains valid - however, the risk lies with the Italian company itself. Should the substantive requirements later be found not to have been met, the Italian subsidiary, acting as withholding agent (i.e. the entity legally required to levy the tax), would be liable for the taxes not withheld.

This same substantive approach is confirmed by the practice of the Italian Revenue Agency. In rulings n. 537/2021 and n. 48/2025, the Agency acknowledged – within the framework of the cooperative compliance regime (Italy’s cooperative compliance programme for large taxpayers) – the possibility of applying the exemption even before the minimum holding period has elapsed, subject to the obligation to recover the tax if the requirement is ultimately not satisfied. The same logic has been extended to the interest regime in response to tax ruling n. 49/2025.

Further confirmation comes from the Court of Justice of the European Union, which in its judgment of 5 March 2026 in Case C-828/24, concerning Directive 2003/49/EC on interest and royalties, held that the exemption may also apply to periods preceding the submission of the relevant certificate, provided that the substantive requirements laid down by EU law are satisfied. The Court also ruled that Member States cannot introduce temporal restrictions not provided for under EU law.

Although that decision concerns the interest and royalties directive, the principles it establishes are fully consistent with those developed under the parent-subsidiary Directive: both pursue the same objective, namely the elimination of double taxation and the prevention of purely formal requirements from obstructing intra-group financial flows.

What does all this mean in practice? For multinational groups with Italian subsidiaries, the message is clear: a delay in producing the parent company’s tax residence certificate does not result in the loss of the exemption from withholding tax on dividends, provided that the substantive requirements laid down by the Parent-Subsidiary Directive are satisfied at the time of payment. Legal certainty has increased, but vigilance should not be lowered. The Italian subsidiary, acting as withholding agent, remains directly liable for any unpaid withholding taxes if—during a tax audit—it is established that the substantive requirements were not in fact met. A careful ex ante review, carried out before any dividend distribution, therefore remains an essential step.​​​​

from our newsletter

​​​​​Tax Newsletter​​​​​​​

author

Contact Person Picture

Giorgia Cavallari

Certified Tax Consultant, Statutory Auditor (Italy)

Associate Partner

+39 02 6328 841

Send inquiry

Profile

Contact Person Picture

Martina Erbeia

Degree in Economy (Italy)

Junior Associate

+39 02 6328 841

Send inquiry

Profile

our services

Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Deutschland Weltweit Search Menu