We use cookies to personalise the website and offer you the greatest added value. They are, among other purposes, used to analyse visitor usage in order to improve the website for you. By using this website, you agree to their use. Further information can be found in our data privacy statement.



Donation of shareholdings and control: the Court of Cassation and the 2024 reform

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​published on 17 April 2026 | reading time approx. 4 minutes

​

The donation of bare ownership of company shares, with the donor retaining the right of usufruct, is one of the most commonly used tools in planning the generational transfer of Italian family businesses. This structure allows the ownership of the shares to be transferred to descendants, whilst the donor retains the usufruct and, within the limits set out in the deed, certain administrative rights, with potential advantages also in terms of inheritance and gift tax.

Two recent rulings by the Court of Cassation — Nos. 6614 and 6616, both dated 19 March 2026 — address an area of application that has generated significant uncertainty in practice: whether and to what extent the reservation of voting rights in favour of the usufructuary is compatible with the control requirement necessary to qualify for the exemption.

The rulings form part of a regulatory framework recently amended by Legislative Decree 139/2024, with effect from 1 January 2025. A coordinated reading of the case law and the reform is therefore essential for the correct structuring of transfer transactions.

The previous regime and Rulings Nos. 6614 and 6616/2026

Under the previous regime of Article 3, paragraph 4-ter, of Legislative Decree 346/1990, exemption from inheritance and gift tax for the transfer of shareholdings in limited companies was subject to the condition that the beneficiary acquired control within the meaning of Article 2359(1)(1) of the Civil Code, i.e. the availability of the majority of voting rights exercisable at the ordinary general meeting.

In the cases examined by the Court, the donor had transferred to his children the bare ownership of a controlling shareholding in a limited liability company, reserving the usufruct for himself. The deed of donation provided, however, that the right to vote on the distribution of profits remained with the usufructuary, whilst the bare owners voted on the remaining resolutions of the general meeting.

The donees had undertaken to maintain control for five years and requested the exemption be applied. The Revenue Agency had denied the benefit, considering that the control requirement had not been met. The Court of Cassation confirmed this approach.

The Court’s reasoning

The rulings clarify that the control relevant for the purposes of exemption is majority control and cannot be understood in partial or selective terms.

This requirement implies that the beneficiary must be in a position to influence the resolutions of the ordinary general meeting without any essential matters being excluded. According to the Court, these include the resolution on the distribution of profits, which affects the company’s economic and financial balance and relations between shareholders.

The reservation of the right to vote on this matter to the u​sufructuary therefore means that the donee does not acquire the legal control required by the provision, with the consequent inapplicability of the exemption.
The decisive factor is the completeness of the transfer of control.

In this sense, the rulings are in line with the guidance already provided by the Revenue Agency in response no. 271/2025, in which the exemption was recognized where there was an agreement capable of conferring on the donees a majority of voting rights at the ordinary general meeting, including the resolution on the distribution of profits.

The current regime: the changes introduced by Legislative Decree 139/2024

The rulings in question refer to the previous regime, applicable to gifts made up to 31 December 2024. From 1 January 2025, the new text of Article 3, paragraph 4-ter, of Legislative Decree 346/1990, as amended by Legislative Decree 139/2024, applies.

The reform confirms the requirement of de jure control pursuant to Article 2359(1)(1) of the Civil Code as a condition for eligibility for the exemption on the transfer of shareholdings in limited companies. In this respect, the guidance provided by case law remains fully relevant even within the new regulatory framework.
The main innovations, however, concern other aspects: the extension of the relief to cases of consolidation of existing control, overcoming previous interpretative uncertainties; the recognition of the exemption also for pure holding companies and property companies, regardless of whether they directly carry out a business activity; the extension to transfers of shareholdings in companies resident in Member States of the European Union, the European Economic Area or in states with adequate exchange of information.

Operational considerations

Rulings Nos. 6614 and 6616/2026 confirm that, in generational transfer transactions, the rules governing voting rights play a central role in verifying the control requirement.

Where structures exist that provide for the separation of bare ownership and usufruct, particular attention must be paid to the allocation of administrative rights. The donor’s retention of voting rights on essential matters at the ordinary general meeting — including the distribution of profits — may compromise access to the exemption scheme.

The bare ownership–usufruct structure remains, in itself, compatible with the preferential regime, but requires precise calibration of the clauses relating to the exercise of voting rights, in order to ensure the effective transfer of control to the beneficiaries.

Under the regulatory framework in force from 2025, the broadening of the scope of application of the relief makes such instruments even more relevant in planning for generational transfer. However, the substantive verification of the legal control requirement remains central, in light of the interpretative criteria provided by case law.

from our newsletter

​​​​​Tax News​​letter​​​​​​

author

Contact Person Picture

Stefano Damagino

Certified Tax Consultant, Statutory Auditor (Italy)

Associate Partner

+39 02 6328 841

Send inquiry

Profile

Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Deutschland Weltweit Search Menu